Prosumer ?
Glanced at the announcement for the revision to the Macbook lines.
The main change makes the entire notebook line very disposable. Sure notebooks tend to be that way. However the Macbook Pros are supposed to be aimed at a “Professional” market. As nebulous as that can be.
To my mind the logical lineup is a basic feature set that grows as you move up the line. Firewire and express card slot should be part of that basic set at least for 15″ and 17″.
Apple appear to have bowed to pressure and brought back firewire to the 13″. This makes it a very tempting small machine that I’d seriously consider. Even with the combined audio in / out jacks.
Interesting that they’ve brought back a 15″ at the old mid $2K price bracket. Look closely though. Its a high end 13″ with a 15″ screen. There is no discrete video card.
The big issue I have is the removal of the express card slot from the 15″. Apparently the SD memory card reader is considered more useful. That slot offered a good amount of flexibility for a notebook. As such its a deal breaker if I was in the market for a new 15″.
This leaves the 17″ as the “Professional” machine. But its a desktop replacement with quite a price tag and needs a chiropractor to help with the attendant back ache from hauling it around.
I can see why they’ve gone with a sealed battery. I’ve not got confirmation but I’d say the user replaceable memory and drive feature has probably gone as well. The benefits to Apple are two fold, customers are forced to order their upgrades up front (so improved options sales) and not needing to stock so many pesky batteries.
Where the designs appear to have gone as user friendly as possible. Its flipped the other way completely. No room for improvements. Totally sealed units.
I’m of two minds. Given my usage is fairly average these are not problematic. But for a media professional that’s quite a lot of limitations if they’re wanting to be totally portable. Once that battery is drained, good luck with finding a power point.
I don’t believe that Apple are saving on production costs by removing such features. Some just don’t make sense, like firewire. They’ve done it before and brought it back to the 15″. Its just odd. The designers seem to work in a bubble or at least have a very specific user requirement in mind.
By and large this works to their benefit. However this just seems to emphasise how disposable notebooks are becoming. Guess my next upgrade can wait for the next revision. Not that that’s a significant change.
Corrections:
The fun of leaping in boots and all. Apparently the Mac Book Pros can be upgraded by removing the bottom plate. Not as huge an issue as I initially thought.
According to Anandtech, the revised batteries grant significantly greater battery life. Staggeringly so based on their tests. So the tradeoff is the EC card slot being taken up by battery it seems. The 15″ almost doubles its battery life.
Thats not insubstantial. Well worth considering.